Role essentialism - Revision history

Admin: Redirected page to Role Essentialism

2014-03-25T17:06:21Z

Redirected page to Role Essentialism

2014-03-25T17:06:09Z

Redirected page to Role essentialism

2014-03-18T22:14:09Z

Reverted edits by 67.248.213.169 (talk) to last revision by Admin

2014-03-18T21:23:08Z

fuck you

2014-03-18T21:18:50Z

lol practices? there's no "practice" associated with a concept. you don't practice the concept. it is what it is. you define it and then you're done.

2014-03-18T21:17:12Z

there's a citation supporting the criticism of role essentialism, but no citation supporting the criticism of the criticism

2014-03-14T02:07:14Z

2014-03-14T01:56:03Z

‎Criticisms

2014-03-14T01:52:00Z

2014-03-10T13:18:46Z

@@ Line 1: / Line 1: @@
-The term "role essentialism" was used in 2011 by [[Thomas M. Millar]]. [http://yesmeansyesblog.wordpress.com/2011/05/02/domism-role-essentialism-and-sexism-intersectionality-in-the-bdsm-scene/]
+#redirect[[Role essentialism]]
-−
-From that essay, the term is linked to the following pernicious and false ideas:
-−
-* The idea that a person has a certain innate, natural, or static [[BDSM]] [[Status Roles| role]].
-* The idea that a certain bdsm role [[One true way|necessarily has certain features]].
-* The idea that a person's BDSM role is determined by [[Gender| gender]].
-−
-Role essentialism is upheld in scenes by [[role policing]].
-−
-−
-== Best Practices ==
-−
-== Criticisms ==
-−
-Role essentialism is sometimes criticized because while a message of avoiding [[one true way| one true wayism]] is present and important, that definitions often are stripped down or diluted to the point where much of the implied meaning, nuance and associated [[best practices]] with an aspect of BDSM may be lost in translation.  This view itself assumes that some levels of role essentialism can have a positive and educational effect.
-−
-[[Category:BDSM Theory]]

@@ Line 10: / Line 10: @@
-== Criticisms ==
+== Best Practices ==
-The idea that "role essentialism" is a bad thing is sometimes criticized {{By whom}} because while a message of avoiding [[one true way| one true wayism]] is present {{citation needed}} and important, that definitions often are stripped down or diluted to the point where much of the implied meaning, nuance and associated [[best practices]] with an aspect of BDSM may be lost. This view itself assumes that some levels of role essentialism can have a positive and educational effect.
+== Criticisms ==
-However, if, rather than "assuming" (with no motivation) that it has a positive effect, one actually looks at the evidence (Millar, 2011), one sees that it in fact has a negative effect.
+Role essentialism is sometimes criticized because while a message of avoiding [[one true way| one true wayism]] is present and important, that definitions often are stripped down or diluted to the point where much of the implied meaning, nuance and associated [[best practices]] with an aspect of BDSM may be lost in translation.  This view itself assumes that some levels of role essentialism can have a positive and educational effect.
 [[Category:BDSM Theory]]

@@ Line 12: / Line 12: @@
 == Criticisms ==
-The idea that "role essentialism" is a bad thing is sometimes criticized {{By whom}} because while a message of avoiding [[one true way| one true wayism]] is present {{citation needed}} and important, that definitions often are stripped down or diluted to the point where much of the implied meaning, nuance and associated [[best practices]] with an aspect of BDSM may be lost in translation.  This view itself assumes that some levels of role essentialism can have a positive and educational effect.
+The idea that "role essentialism" is a bad thing is sometimes criticized {{By whom}} because while a message of avoiding [[one true way| one true wayism]] is present {{citation needed}} and important, that definitions often are stripped down or diluted to the point where much of the implied meaning, nuance and associated [[best practices]] with an aspect of BDSM may be lost. This view itself assumes that some levels of role essentialism can have a positive and educational effect.
 [[Category:BDSM Theory]]

← Older revision		Revision as of 21:18, 18 March 2014
Line 9:		Line 9:
	Role essentialism is upheld in scenes by [[role policing]].		Role essentialism is upheld in scenes by [[role policing]].

−
−	~~== Best Practices ==~~

	== Criticisms ==		== Criticisms ==

← Older revision		Revision as of 02:07, 14 March 2014
Line 16:		Line 16:
	Role essentialism is sometimes criticized because while a message of avoiding [[one true way\| one true wayism]] is present and important, that definitions often are stripped down or diluted to the point where much of the implied meaning, nuance and associated [[best practices]] with an aspect of BDSM may be lost in translation. This view itself assumes that some levels of role essentialism can have a positive and educational effect.		Role essentialism is sometimes criticized because while a message of avoiding [[one true way\| one true wayism]] is present and important, that definitions often are stripped down or diluted to the point where much of the implied meaning, nuance and associated [[best practices]] with an aspect of BDSM may be lost in translation. This view itself assumes that some levels of role essentialism can have a positive and educational effect.

−	~~Compare~~: ~~Culturally Exclusive, One True Way, Best Practices~~	+	[[Category:BDSM Theory]]

← Older revision		Revision as of 01:52, 14 March 2014
Line 8:		Line 8:

	Role essentialism is upheld in scenes by [[role policing]].		Role essentialism is upheld in scenes by [[role policing]].
		+
		+	== Criticisms ==
		+
		+	Role essentialism is sometimes criticized because while a message of avoiding [[one true way\| one true wayism]] is present and important, that definitions often are stripped down or diluted to the point where much of the implied meaning, nuance and associated [[best practices]] with an aspect of BDSM may be lost in translation. This view itself assumes that some levels of role essentialism can have a positive and educational effect.